Canadian Electrical Industry News Week

 

Nov 24, 2017

Lighting ControlSteve Mesh

Networked lighting control systems are all the rage these days. Rightfully so, given their enormous capability to control luminaires, energy use — and potentially much more. But what are the major elements that define a networked lighting control system? Understanding this will help the specifier to decide which system to use on a project.

Wired vs. wireless

The biggest buzz word in the controls industry today is probably “wireless”. This means that the lighting control system wirelessly connects components in its network (via radios embedded into each component). Other systems are “wired”, in which case physical wires connect the control system components. Some hybrid systems are designed to connect certain components wirelessly, but others via wires. What is transmitted through this network regardless of whether it’s transmitted wirelessly or through physical wires? Instructions are sent from a central server to luminaires and potentially other devices as well (e.g., thermostats for HVAC systems) — for example to dim, turn on or turn off. Data are returned to the central server; for example, from occupancy sensors, photosensors or switches. The information from those “peripheral” devices goes to the central server, which in turn sends instructions back to luminaires. Additionally, information about the luminaires is returned to the central server; for example, about whether the luminaire is on or off, its dimmed level, power draw based on current dimmed level, etc.

The biggest benefit to using wireless systems is the ease of installation and, therefore, potentially reduced labour cost. Additionally, if the luminaire vendor can pre-install “controllers” as well as sensors on a per-fixture basis, then the electrical contractor only has to connect power wires just as with any other fixture. Plus, they typically don’t have to have any knowledge about networked lighting control systems to complete the installation. One potential drawback to using a control system that connects components wirelessly is that it may be less secure than a wired system. If you’re specifying a control system for a project where the client is extremely sensitive about security, this may not be the best solution. Lastly, wireless signal propagation isn’t always foolproof. The radios used in these components are typically low-power. Plus, the signal may have a hard time travelling long distances and going through interior partitions. It’s very important to heed a vendor’s recommendations for maximum distance between components and gateways.

Using wires to establish a network to connect all components in a lighting control system may provide more security, or at the very minimum more peace of mind to an owner who is concerned about hacking. It may also reduce the potential for the signal to drop out due to propagation problems. However, these wires are invariably low-voltage — typically Ethernet cable or a pair of low-voltage cable such as 18/2 (a pair of 18-gauge wires). As such, they are susceptible to voltage drop over long distances. So the specifier should still heed the vendor’s recommendations for maximum distance between components.

Remember that the network does not transmit “dimming” signals. The network connecting all components only transmits instructions telling luminaires and other devices what to do, and then the luminaires internally tell their ballasts or drivers to dim, etc. (usually using an analog 0-10V signal). As such, the network data is entirely digital. Be aware that there are systems that use centralized controllers that send 0-10V dimming signals to a group of fixtures, but these are the exception to the rule.

Topology

Networks in lighting control systems can be connected in different ways, especially in a wireless system. One of the more prevalent patterns is a “self-healing mesh network”. That means that any “node” (component) can connect to/communicate with any other node. If a particular node isn’t working for any reason at all, the signal simply tries to find another nearby node (hence the “self-healing” phraseology). Some wireless systems use a “star” topology to connect all components to a gateway. (“Gateways” are essentially wireless routers that transmit wirelessly back and forth to components — luminaires, sensors, switches, etc., and are wired back to the central server.) In a star topology, every device must establish a connection to the gateway on its own. Some systems using a star topology allow you to make any device into a “repeater.” The amount of data flow through a system with a star pattern is typically less than in a self-healing mesh network, so there may be an impact on frequency of data transmission, reliability, etc. Using a system with a star topology may reduce the likelihood of having transmission problems. However, if any component’s radio has difficulty connecting with the gateway, some other component in between can be turned into a repeater to help establish the connection.

Wired systems typically use a “daisy-chain” topology to connect components back to either gateways (similarly to a wireless system) or in some cases directly to a central server. In some systems, a strict daisy-chain topology must be maintained — meaning no sub-loops, “T” connections, etc. Other systems allow any type of topology as long as everything is ultimately connected back to a gateway or server. It’s important to note that in both wireless as well as wired systems, it’s common to have more than one “loop” or group of components connected to a gateway or central server. For example, on a large office floor, a wireless system may use four (or more) wireless gateways (obviously depending on size and the number of components). A wired system may have four (or more) “loops” of network wire. That’s why most systems use gateways similarly to any other computer network to manage all of the components that must be incorporated into the overall system (and ultimately connected to a central server).

Software

So far, we’ve only touched on the hardware. While that’s important, it’s probably even more impactful to consider how the system’s software works. What is the “UI” like (user interface)? What capabilities does the software have, or not have? Who can access the system, make changes, etc.? As you might imagine, differences in software are only limited by the imagination, so it could take a semester-long class just to scratch the surface in understanding the different approaches taken by vendors.

Fortunately, lighting control systems all have to do more or less the same basic things. For example, they have to take information from sources such as occupancy sensors, photosensors and switches, process that information, then instruct luminaires how to behave. They typically have to provide a timing method (such as NTP, Network Time Protocol) in order to facilitate a scheduling function. Obviously, every system has to have some method to discover devices on its network. However, different systems do sometimes have surprising variations in how they deal with certain aspects of what a lighting control system has to do.

A perfect case in point is “zoning.” Some spaces are fairly simple or fairly small. In those situations, simple zoning may suffice. For example, the space may be divided into a very limited number of zones, in which each component (such as a switch, occupancy sensor or photosensor) belongs to its respective zone as required. What if the space is much larger or much more complex? For example, in a large open-office floor, luminaires in primary and secondary daylight zones must be automatically controlled by photosensors. Additionally, it’s common to use occupancy sensors to achieve the “automatic shutoff” requirement in most codes. It’s becoming commonplace to use a dense pattern of occupancy sensors, but you may only want to use the least amount of photosensors since all luminaires facing a particular exposure can use the information from only one photosensor to dim to appropriate levels. In that case, the “zones” for occupancy sensors may overlap the zones for the photosensors, or vice versa. Not all vendors allow for this complexity of zoning in their software, believe it or not. If they do not, then you might be forced to purchase and install a photosensor in every single occupancy sensor zone.

This is only one example of how the software may be wildly different in different systems, but there are many others. The most important thing is — caveat emptor! If you need the software to behave in very particular ways, it is your responsibility to look for a lighting control system that meets your specifications. There is no standardization for how software works in lighting control systems at this time. So check out the differences in both software and hardware with any systems you are considering for use. That way you should be able to eliminate any surprises once the system has been installed and commissioned.

Steven Mesh is an award-winning lighting designer who has designed lighting and control systems for a variety of project types (commercial, museums, schools, residential, restaurants, retail, historic, healthcare, etc.). As an educator, he has taught classes and given presentations about lighting and controls across North America and internationally. One of his is developing lighting and lighting controls courses that rely on hands-on and/or interactive content. He has been a repeat speaker at LightFair for eight years.

Published with the permission of Lighting Control Association.

 

 

Changing Scene

  • Prev
 Electro-Federation Canada (EFC) announced the launch of its new brand identity last ...
WANTED: Skilled Electrician. Apprentice. or Team  Must be able to perform a simple wiring ...
  Malcolm Bird, General Manager of Fusetek, and Frank Dunnigan, CEO of Techspan Industries, ...
  EiKO, a manufacturer and distributor of premium lighting products, is expanding its ...
  The new CSA C83-17 offers utilities a comprehensive list of components, with critical ...
  Schneider Electric Canada has just launched Go Green in the City 2018, its global ...
  A new report published by Philips Lighting and SmartCitiesWorld highlights drivers and ...
This ongoing study provides industry with information on the most up-to-date issues and statistics ...

 Electrician Forum Brought to You by Schneider Electric             

The Electrician Forum is a monthly column that provides valuable information to electricians and electrical contractors on current industry trends and concerns. 

Schneider ElectricSponsored by Schneider Electric

In this issue: 

Quite simply put if you feel that job site costing and quote development are a lot of work, you are right! To properly assess a job and estimate the required work time, product costs and various other expenses can take more time than is often feasible for a small company. You need to be spending your time completing projects, which can become difficult if you are spending your hours doing cost analysis. We learned this first hand in last month’s edition of the Electrician Forum when Steve Beeby of Beehive Electric discussed the balance required to own and operate an electrical contracting company.

read more...

Watch a portion of the interview conducted by Electrical Industry Canada with Steve Beeby of Beehive Electric

 

Codes and Regulations Brought to You by the CSA Group

  • Prev
In this article: Section 58 — Passenger Ropeways and Similar Equipment. Rule 58-000 ...
  Unauthorized CSA Group certification marks have been found on wiring by Triumph Cable ...
In this article: Section 52 — Diagnostic imaging installations. The CE code is a ...
In this article: Section 46 — Emergency Power Supply, Unit Equipment, Exit Signs, and ...
  In this article: Section 44 — Theatre Installations. The CE Code is a ...
CSA has published C22.2 No. 60947-7-3, the harmonized standard for low-voltage switchgear and ...
  Electric welders. The CE Code is a comprehensive document. Sometimes it can seem ...
  In this article: Section 40 — Electric cranes and hoists. The CE Code is a ...

Fluke Hammon Healy

As our population grows and consumers continue to rely on technology for both essentials and comfort, the need for power quality has become vital. Fluke is a leader in this field, offering power quality training seminars, as well as employing power quality specialists with years of industry experience.

This month’s personal profile is a double feature of two of Fluke’s senior power quality specialists, Hilton Hammond and Frank Healy.

Hilton Hammond has been with Fluke since 1995, and in 2013 moved into his current position as Power Quality Business Unit Manager. He has a deep and thorough knowledge of power quality and related electrical instrumentation. 

Frank Healy, Power Quality Product Marketing Manager at Fluke since 2006, has been in the industry for well over three decades. He globally manages Fluke’s power quality products, including measuring instruments and precision power analyzers.

Read More



Tools for the Trade

  • Prev
  IDEAL Industries has introduced Combination Drill Taps to its tool lineup. Combining the ...
  Stripping and crimping device, 100 - 240 V input voltage, for insulated ferrules with a ...
Professional all-in-one cutter/stripper for coaxial and twisted pair cables     ...
  Klein Tools' Coax Explorrer 2 tests coaxial cable and maps up to 4 locations   ...
  Ideal Industries' T-14 wire stripper s are ideal for all professionals working within the ...
  The ATS850 conveyor eliminates all types of electro static discharge requirements. ...
  Lorik Tool & Automation has the experience and ability to manufacture a variety of ...
  Ideal Industries' 26 piece insulated Journeyman kit is ideal for new electricians or for ...
  Klein Tools Deluxe Fish Rod Set comes in 19 pieces that when assembled can fish wire and ...
  BendWorks Software was designed to help electrical contractors adopt this new process ...

Product News

  • Prev
  With its new high-intensity PODIS® LED lamps, WIELAND offers pluggable, ...
  As easy as pick, slip and apply!  This intuitive multi-tool is designed to help ...
  Designed to easily fit into panels or busbars where space may be ...
SGi’s 1 watt dimmable StarBurst LED Step Light promotes equal amounts of beauty and safety. ...
The Nova UAC-P 2500W is a larger emergency lighting power supply than Beghelli’s classic Nova ...
Brady’s new BradyPrinter i5100 industrial label printer offers intelligent print capabilities ...
Standard has launched a new product in its Lumeina downlight series: this 6-watt module is now ...
  The integrated systems simplify specification, sourcing and installation, and procure a ...
  Pioneer Lighting now offers a full line of low profile LED surface strips with a wide ...
  The LUNA Series by Liteline, sits proudly between a premium integrated LED ...

 

Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
David Johns is a unique and dedicated individual both at home and in the workplace. At home he is a ...
    Sean Freeman is a vibrant, enthusiastic and selfless individual who has taken his ...
  Automation companies are drivers of innovation, and have penetrated near every industry ...
Total Electrical Solutions was founded in 2013 by Jeremy Herrington in Quispamsis, on the outskirts ...
Andrew MacLeod is a territory sales manager with Leviton Manufacturing of Canada in British ...
  Floyd Lau founded Amptek Technologies in 2002 as an end to end engineering design ...
Mike Marsh, President and CEO of SaskPower, has been a leading figure in Saskatchewan’s ...
Gordon MacDonald is a cheerful, driven individual who loves to be challenged, a trait that suits ...
  Most of us have a difficult enough time managing one job and a home life. However, some ...
  Since 2012 Barnstormer has advanced the abilities of their brewery with the installation ...

Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
2016 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil